Those forearms, those ridiculously beautiful forearms.
I blame them for all of this.
Before the forearms arrived, I had built a perfectly functional life in which men were largely theoretical. I had been single for twelve years and, despite the cultural assumption that a woman alone must be waiting for someone to arrive and complete the set, I was doing absolutely fine. Better than fine, actually. I worked, travelled, raised children, accumulated cats, went to the theatre, booked hotel rooms, ate alone in restaurants and developed the sort of self-sufficiency that becomes almost architectural. My life had structure. It had rhythm. It had very little romantic chaos in it.
Then came a man with absurdly beautiful forearms and, very inconveniently, reminded me that companionship can be lovely.
This was rude of him.
Because once you remember what it feels like to have someone woven into the banal little corners of your day, silence becomes much louder. The messages about nothing. The photograph from a train window. The ridiculous observation you know only one person will understand. The “did you get home okay?” and the “look at this” and the “you’ll never guess what just happened.” None of these things are grand enough to make it into a romantic film montage, but they are the things that create intimacy. They make life feel shared.
And that, I think, is the really irritating revelation.
I am happy alone. I also want someone.
Those two things are not contradictory, although people seem determined to pretend they are. There is a strange cultural binary where a woman must either be fiercely independent and need absolutely nobody, or she must be wandering around like Jane Austen’s least fortunate heroine hoping a man with land will notice her. I reject both options. I can assemble my own furniture and still want someone to send me a stupid meme at eleven o’clock at night.
I do not need rescuing. I do not need completing. I do not need choosing.
I would, however, quite like company.
Preferably intelligent company. Funny company. Emotionally literate company. Someone who will walk around a pumpkin farm with me, tolerate my extremely strong opinions about rom-coms, understand why The Holiday is clearly superior to Love Actually, and not behave as though replying to a message is an act of wartime heroism.
This is apparently where the modern dating landscape begins to deteriorate.
My return to dating has felt less like a Nora Ephron film and more like a poorly funded behavioural science study conducted by men with Wi-Fi.
There was Sweetpea.
Sweetpea appeared after a period of communication so erratic that I had begun to wonder whether the conversation itself had been a hallucination. Then, without warning, there it was. Sweetpea.
Sweetpea?
Sir.
You cannot vanish into the wilderness and then return with a term of endearment as though no administrative incident has occurred. There should be forms. There should be a debrief. At minimum, I require minutes from the meeting where you decided silence followed by “Sweetpea” constituted a communication strategy.
It was so audaciously casual that I almost admired it.
Almost.
And then we came to Doctor Who.
Now, I am a Doctor Who person. This is not obscure information. There is a TARDIS-shaped section of my personality that has been there for most of my life, so when I mentioned seeing the TARDIS at an exhibition years ago I assumed I was discussing something safely within the realm of normal human conversation.
I was then asked whether it had actually travelled through time.
There are moments in life when your brain simply refuses to process the information it has been given because accepting it would require too much structural rearrangement.
This was one of those moments.
I looked at my phone. I looked away from my phone. I looked back at my phone in case the words had somehow altered themselves while unsupervised.
They had not.
This man is educated. Not “once completed a pub quiz” educated. Properly educated. Degrees. Multiple postgraduate degrees. The sort of academic history that would ordinarily suggest at least a passing familiarity with the distinction between science fiction and the current capabilities of terrestrial engineering.
And yet there I was, contemplating the possibility that an adult human being genuinely believed the BBC had mastered time travel and quietly deployed it for exhibition purposes.
Imagine the meeting.
“Excellent news, everyone. We have finally broken the laws of physics.”
“Extraordinary. Shall we inform NASA?”
“No, put it next to a Cyberman in Cardiff.”
This is dating now.
Not candlelit dinners. Not meaningful glances across crowded rooms. Not Meg Ryan and Tom Hanks falling in love over dial-up internet.
No.
It is me staring at WhatsApp wondering whether I now need to explain that David Tennant cannot actually regenerate either.
The maddening thing is that none of this would bother me quite so much if I had not recently remembered what good communication feels like.
That is the legacy of the forearms.
For twelve years, there was no comparison. My life was quiet and self-contained and I did not particularly notice the absence of romantic intimacy because I had forgotten the texture of it. Then someone came along and, for a while, there were messages every day. There was anticipation. There was someone at the other end of the phone who knew the context, remembered the previous chapter and understood why the completely inconsequential thing I was telling him mattered to me.
And then it ended.
What surprised me afterwards was not simply that I missed him. Sometimes I did. Sometimes, in certain moments, I still do.
What I missed just as much was movement.
The sense that something might happen.
The tiny electrical current running beneath ordinary life.
There is a particular kind of excitement in knowing another person is thinking about you somewhere else. It changes the shape of the day. The world feels fractionally more cinematic. Train journeys become scenes. Songs acquire meaning they absolutely did not ask for. A perfume becomes so entangled with one particular person that you eventually have to retire it from service because otherwise you risk being emotionally ambushed in your own bedroom.
Romance is frankly very inefficient.
Dating apps offer a synthetic version of that excitement. There is always another profile, another possibility, another little burst of dopamine when someone matches with you. For approximately seven minutes you can imagine that perhaps this is the one who will turn out to be interesting, available, emotionally articulate and capable of answering a message without entering a fugue state.
Then he asks whether the TARDIS actually time travelled.
Hope is exhausting.
And yet, despite the evidence, I still seem to possess some.
This may be my most troubling personality trait.
Because I know what I want now, and irritatingly, it is not unreasonable.
I want consistency.
I want curiosity.
I want someone who is delighted by me rather than vaguely willing to tolerate my existence.
I want someone who can say, “I’m really busy today, but I’ll message you tomorrow,” and then, in an extraordinary demonstration of advanced civilisation, actually do it.
I do not want to conduct forensic analysis of punctuation.
I do not want to spend three days wondering whether a man is overwhelmed, avoidant, busy, dead or simply incapable of operating WhatsApp.
I do not want one message a day.
I do not want breadcrumbing dressed up as a personality trait.
I do not want “I’m just bad at texting” from someone who apparently manages to communicate successfully with colleagues, friends, family, Deliveroo and the tax office.
Most importantly, I do not want to be hidden.
I have done enough shrinking in my lifetime.
I do not want the sort of relationship that can only exist privately, carefully protected from parents or friends or colleagues or whatever imagined audience might disapprove. I do not want to become somebody’s secret adventure, exciting precisely because I am kept separate from the rest of their life.
If you want me, I want you to want all of me.
The woman with the children and the cats and the internet career and the loud laugh and the opinions and the toy empire and the complicated brain.
Not a sanitised version that fits neatly into whatever space you have decided I am allowed to occupy.
Maybe this is what happens when you reach your fifties.
You stop auditioning.
You stop thinking, “I hope he likes me,” and start thinking, “Do I actually like him?”
That change sounds small, but it is seismic.
I do not want to be chosen. I want to choose.
That means I can find someone attractive and still decide he is not right for me. I can enjoy someone’s attention without allowing it to become the organising principle of my emotional life. I can miss someone without believing that missing them means I should return to them.
I can even acknowledge, with great dignity, that a man possesses spectacular forearms without allowing those forearms to override every other available piece of evidence.
Growth.
The forearms remain extremely good, obviously.
I am not going to lie for the sake of personal development.
But beautiful forearms cannot sustain a relationship.
This has been a difficult day for the forearm community.
The bigger lesson, though, is not really about dating apps or WhatsApp or postgraduate men asking questions about fictional time machines.
It is about what happened when I let someone into a life that had been closed to romantic intimacy for twelve years.
I discovered that I had not stopped wanting love.
I had simply adapted to its absence.
There is something both comforting and devastating about that.
Human beings are extraordinarily good at adaptation. We build a life around whatever remains. We learn new routes. We rearrange the furniture. We stop reaching for things that are no longer there.
Eventually, the absence itself becomes ordinary.
Then someone arrives and suddenly you remember the room used to have another door.
That is what the forearms did.
They opened the door.
The bastard.
And now I have to live with the knowledge that I would quite like someone beside me sometimes.
Not every day. God, no. I have spent too many years sleeping diagonally and controlling my own thermostat to surrender civilisation completely.
Long term, not full time.
I want a person who has their own life and wants me in it. Someone who can be deeply committed without believing that love requires constant proximity. Someone who understands that independence is not rejection and intimacy is not ownership.
I want someone whose brain makes mine light up.
Someone capable of discussing absurd things seriously and serious things without becoming absurd.
Someone who will go to the theatre, take a train, wander around Edinburgh, sit in a hotel bar, argue about films and eventually understand why I own quite so many NeeDohs.
Someone who, when something wonderful happens, is the person I instinctively want to tell.
That is the bit I miss.
Not being rescued.
Being witnessed.
There is a difference.
So I remain here, somewhere between romantic optimism and “I genuinely cannot be bothered with this shit.”
I still have my life.
A very full, ridiculous, occasionally extraordinary life.
There are four cats. There are children I adore. There are books beside the bed and trains to catch and places I have not visited yet. There is work that frequently involves me sitting in my house surrounded by squishy toys while discussing them on the internet as though this is a perfectly normal profession.
There are films to watch and essays to write and entire days that belong only to me.
I am not waiting for someone to begin my life.
My life is already happening.
I would simply quite like someone lovely to wander into it and stay.
Someone consistent.
Someone curious.
Someone capable of communicating.
Someone who understands that Doctor Who is fictional.
The bar is, at this point, in a fascinating location.
And maybe that is why I am not entirely cynical yet.
Because those ridiculously beautiful forearms, irritating though their consequences have been, reminded me of something I had almost forgotten.
Love is not necessary for a life to be meaningful.
But wanting love does not make the life you already have insufficient.
You can be complete and still make room.
You can be independent and still want to reach for someone’s hand.
You can have built an entire universe by yourself and still think it might be rather lovely if someone occasionally came over to visit.
So yes, I blame the forearms.
Those forearms.
Those ridiculously beautiful forearms.
They opened Pandora’s box, reintroduced me to longing and sent me back into a dating ecosystem where grown men may or may not believe in functional TARDIS technology.
Honestly, they had better have been worth it.